The request
{
"name": "wever_evaluation-result-check",
"arguments": {
"claims": [
{
"id": "c1",
"text": "Resolves 92 percent of billing questions",
"metric": "resolution rate",
"value": 92,
"subset": "English questions",
"subset_disclosed": false
},
{
"id": "c2",
"text": "Ahead of the version 3 agent",
"metric": "resolution rate",
"value": 84,
"compared_to": "version 3 agent",
"direction": "higher"
}
],
"results": [
{
"metric": "resolution rate",
"subset": "English questions",
"value": 91.7,
"n": 24,
"spread": {
"kind": "ci95",
"value": 11
}
},
{
"metric": "resolution rate",
"value": 84.2,
"n": 400,
"spread": {
"kind": "ci95",
"value": 3.6
},
"conditions": {
"model": "agent v4",
"dataset": "billing questions v4"
}
}
],
"baselines": [
{
"name": "version 3 agent",
"metric": "resolution rate",
"value": 82.5,
"n": 400,
"spread": {
"kind": "ci95",
"value": 3.7
}
}
],
"subsets": {
"run": [
"English questions",
"Spanish questions",
"refund disputes"
],
"reported": [
"English questions"
]
}
}
}What the report returns
Verdict: claims_unsupported.
| Finding, difference within noise | 1 claimed difference sits inside the noise: c2 at 84.2 against 82.5 for version 3 agent, a difference of 1.7 inside the combined 95 percent interval of 7.3. |
|---|
| Finding, subset undisclosed | 1 claim rests on a subset it does not name: c1 rests on English questions without saying so. |
|---|
| Finding, subsets dropped | 2 subsets were run and left out of the report: Spanish questions and refund disputes. |
|---|
| Finding, small sample | 1 figure behind a claim rests on fewer than 30 tasks: resolution rate on English questions (24). |
|---|
| Finding, conditions missing | 1 figure behind a claim is reported without its run conditions: resolution rate on English questions (no model and dataset). |
|---|
| Fix, difference within noise | Score more tasks or repeat the runs until the intervals separate, or state that the difference is within the noise. |
|---|
| Fix, subset undisclosed | Name the subset in the claim itself, beside the full-set figure. |
|---|
| Fix, subsets dropped | Report every subset the evaluation ran, including the ones that scored lower. |
|---|
| Fix, small sample | Score at least 30 tasks for any figure a claim rests on, or state the count beside it. |
|---|
| Fix, conditions missing | Report each figure with its run conditions: the model and version and the dataset and version at least. |
|---|
The claims go beyond the numbers: difference within noise, subset undisclosed and subsets dropped.
The report leads with 92 percent resolved and says the agent is ahead of version 3. The 92 comes from 24 English questions, and the Spanish questions and refund disputes that also ran are left out. Across all 400 questions the agent scores 84.2 against 82.5 for version 3, a gap of 1.7 inside the 7.3 points of noise in the two figures. The report names each of these, so the owner leads with the full-set figure, reports every subset and scores more tasks before claiming the lead.