The request
{
"name": "wever_learning-validation-check",
"arguments": {
"lessons": [
{
"id": "l1",
"lesson": "Confirm the card on file before refunding an order placed before a card change",
"status": "adopted",
"adopted_at": "2026-11-12",
"evidence": 5,
"against": 0,
"tested": true,
"tested_at": "2026-11-11"
},
{
"id": "l2",
"lesson": "Offer store credit first on damaged-item claims",
"status": "adopted",
"adopted_at": "2026-11-14",
"evidence": 1,
"against": 0,
"tested": false
},
{
"id": "l3",
"lesson": "Quote the standard window when the order shows no shipping zone",
"status": "adopted",
"adopted_at": "2026-11-15",
"evidence": 2,
"against": 2,
"tested": true,
"tested_at": "2026-11-16"
}
]
}
}What the report returns
Verdict: anecdote_as_rule.
| Finding, anecdote adopted | 1 lesson was adopted as a standing rule on a single episode or none: l2 (1 supporting episode). |
|---|
| Finding, contradicted adopted | 1 lesson was adopted with as many contradicting episodes as supporting ones: l3 (2 for, 2 against). |
|---|
| Finding, adopted before test | 1 lesson was adopted before the test that should have validated it: l3 (adopted 2026-11-15, tested 2026-11-16). |
|---|
| Finding, adopted untested | 1 lesson was adopted without a test against evidence: l2. |
|---|
| Fix, anecdote adopted | Keep a lesson resting on one episode as a candidate until enough episodes support it. |
|---|
| Fix, contradicted adopted | Retire or rescope an adopted lesson that as many episodes contradict as support. |
|---|
| Fix, adopted before test | Test a lesson against evidence before adopting it, not after. |
|---|
| Fix, adopted untested | Test every lesson against evidence, such as a replay or a held-out set of episodes, before adopting it. |
|---|
Anecdotes have become standing rules: anecdote adopted, contradicted adopted and adopted before test.
The store credit lesson rests on one damaged-item claim and was adopted untested, so a single case now decides every claim like it. The shipping window lesson was adopted a day before its test, with as many episodes against it as for it. The card lesson was tested first, on five refunds, and reads as validated. Moving the store credit lesson back to a candidate and retesting the shipping lesson keeps both open to the next claims that come in.